Monday, May 28, 2012

The Existence of Melody Pond

Okay, so let's go back to Big Bang 2.  River gave Amy the diary to remind her, but let's think about something here.  Aside from the obvious 'how-did-she-get-there?' bit.  How about 'how-does-she-exist'?


Melody was taken as a child, because of the Doctor.  She got to London when her parents were children, and set them up.  Amy told her her alias.  The Doctor gave her the TARDIS diary.  Amy and Rory conceived her on the TARDIS.


Once the universe erased the Doctor, did Amy and Rory even get together?  If they did, how could their daughter grow up and arrive at their wedding, before her own conception?  And how would she find the diary?  Mysteriously found in a gift shop?

No comments:

Post a Comment